I'm so glad that's over. This class was so bad it makes me laugh. We freshman were eager to get to our (for some) first class at Columbia way back in September, so all of us whom were early didn't notice that the teacher was sitting there because of the awkward silence. One student even sat next to Becky and commented on the awkward silence and Becky concurred. What a way for the class to begin! The truth is, the class would have been even better if it were one endless awkward silence and not an attempt at another Core blunder. In essence, University Writing seemed to have the potential of being a sometimes-decent course, but the extremely dull and nervous teaching style crushed all hopes we had. On top of that, the grading seemed somewhat arbitrary- based on what i saw during peer-revision, some of the students in that class truly deserved to fail, but it seemed the more simple and dull or randomly novel your paper was, the better your grade would be. My advice: Either chose to write a very simple essay- or attempt to do something extraordinary with the topic and refrain from consciously attending the class because you will feel as though your brain is collapsing on itself. For 2.5 classes we openly brainstormed different topics and subtopics to pursue in our groups and our final essays, but after we seemed to have narrowed down our focus to 2 very interesting topics Becky came to the next class and politely removed them on the basis that they had nothing to do with our readings and instead mustered up all of her false enthuseasm for the topic of Wall Street which turned out to be even more mind-numbing than it sounded once we devoted a month to it and which had less to do with our readings than the 2 interesting topics we had formed as a class. At best this class is laughable. Hopefully, there will be a couple people in your class that know what they are talking about, one that sleeps with his eyes open, a few whose comments are so pointless that they are entertaining, and one whose attempts at making the class less formal are so asinine that your UW notebook becomes a collection of his quotes. I found that most of my time was spent watching pigeons make fecal stalactites on the opposing building, wishing I had wings and a pea sized cortex.